Hoaxes, myths and prejudice in science: example of Pierre Trémaux
Download PDF
The literature review is an integral part of research. The story of Pierre Trémaux (1818–1895) illustrates how factors, such as hoaxes, fabrications, untrue stories, myths and prejudice, which have nothing to do in science, difficulties in comprehending and accepting new scientific paradigms and also slow and geographically limited dissemination of scientific findings, which results in not being familiar with scientific findings and discoveries elsewhere in the world, are harmful for the ecology of scientific communication. Trémaux and his work are known only based on the correspondence between Karl Marx, who thought that Trémaux’s book was excellent, and Friedrich Engels, who was of the opinion that the book was bad. Trémaux is not included in any standard history of biology although, with his work, he anticipated some theories that others presented as theirs. This primarily refers to theories of punctuated equilibrium, phylogenetic tree, speciation and, consequently, the impact on race theories. From the methodological aspect, the main result of this presentation is the assumption that race theories are a sophisticated ideological means to justify hegemony, imperialism and colonialism, nationalism and discrimination of groups and individuals and other forms of unjust world order between nations, races and individuals in the past, at present and in the future, in the sense that some nations, races and individuals are better than others instead of contributing to the explanation of the differences between them without any judgement.
Related Posts
The paper presents the contributions of participants at the consultation on scientific and professional publications on e-journals at the beginning of the 1990s, which was organised at the Institute of Information Science (IZUM) in Maribor in December 1991. The emphasis is also placed on IZUM’s e-bulletin, which was entered into one of the first directories of e-journals and other e-bulletins worldwide from the same year. Communication is the essence of scientific progress, particularly e-journals.
Continue reading
Wisdom is one of many human mental capabilities. Mental vitality is stereotypically associated with youth and mental decline with old age. However, also aging is a price of wisdom. The connection between neurological decline (senility, dementias) and wisdom development during aging is referred to as the paradox of wisdom.
Continue reading
Dissemination proved to be a complex process that can take very diverse paths with questionable outcomes if not shaped correctly. And there are variety of views in research communities and the society of what the dissemination is. In such a situation it is natural to develop a more solid comprehension of the concept and, based on this, a model of the environment for the dissemination.
Continue reading
Databases are more than just registers providing bibliographic information because of the research history they contain. Database research involves five areas: management, usage, analysis, history/ sociology and methodology /epistemology. A distinction is made between a structural and sociological aspect of databases.
Continue reading
In 2005, Hirsch developed the today commonly known and widely used h-index, the shortest quantitative indicator of the cumulative influence and relevance of the academic work of an individual researcher, a research group or an institution (university, institute, journal, etc.).
Continue reading
